Last week, we engaged in some targeted mini-lessons and learning activities to grow our understanding of tone. We had practiced analyzing tone earlier this fall, but since this is sometimes a challenging concept for 8th graders and because I knew they would have a constructed response about tone on their 2nd quarter benchmark, I designed a few strategic and new learning experiences around tone for my students.
We first began by reviewing some notes on the differences between tone and mood. In addition, we reviewed the differences between denotation and connotation and looked at examples of both. Next, I assigned students picked a partner or trio group to do our table talk activity. We began this activity by reading and watching this excerpt of the “I Have a Dream” speech by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
Students were asked to work with their partner or trio to:
- Identify the tone of the speech.
- Identify specific word choices and/or phrases that created that tone. Students also shared how the connotative or denotative meanings (or both) of their selected words impacted the tone of the speech.
- Groups shared out to the entire class their findings and reflections.
The following day, students were asked to find a passage in their independent reading books OR to choose an alternate text I provided (a selection of poems or informational article). Students then analyzed the tone, following the same procedure from the previous day. I provided a thinking/drafting script for those who wanted to jot down their thoughts in writing first. Students were asked to snap the passage they were analyzing and then post it in their Seesaw account. Students could type a text book with their analysis, record an audio note of their analysis, or type a text note with their analysis. They also labeled the word choices with highlights and/or arrows of the word choices they felt created the tone. I provided a model I completed for them based on my reading of Ordinary Hazards by Nikki Grimes. In addition, I provided a list of positive and negative tone words for students who were struggling to find the right word.
While this task may seem easy to us as adults, it really is challenging for many 8th graders.
We did one more analysis activity of tone, but this time, students read an excerpt of an informational text I pulled from NewsELA. I provided students a drafting template to help them compose a paragraph in which they analyzed the tone of the informational text excerpt. This task was similar to the one on their benchmark. Like the previous activity, I provided an optional list of negative and positive tone words for those who needed/wanted it. For one of my classes, I gave the students of reading the excerpt alone; my 4th period class voted to partner read aloud the excerpt and discuss it before tackling the writing task.
Additional Learning Fun with Gimkit
Depending on the pace of completion, at some points over four days students had an opportunity to play a Gimkit game on tone. As I shared in my previous blog post, I was able to see strengths and weaknesses in understanding of this concept as my kit included many “application” types of questions.
Overall, I felt these learning activities challenged my students and pushed their critical thinking/analysis skills in a variety of ways. What are your favorite strategies for teaching tone to middle or high school students?